Grading Policy

Standard Grade (A Grade)

Standard Grade pins are the highest grade I offer and may have minor cosmetic imperfections (not visible at arm's length). Enamel pins are handmade and even standard pins may have minor imperfections that do not take away from the overall beauty of the pin.

Examples of expected Standard Grade imperfections:

Minor scuffs or scratches on metal
Almost invisible specks in enamel
Slight underfill that can only be seen when tilted / in certain lighting

Minor Flawed (B+ Grade)

Minor Flaw pins include slightly more noticeable imperfections, but ones that do not take away from the overall pin.

Examples of expected Minor Flaw imperfections:

Minor scuffs or scratches on metal
Small marks in enamel
Slight metal plating defects (excluding sides/backs)
Slight underfill or texture that can only be seen when tilted / in certain lighting

Seconds Grade (B Grade/Flawed)

Seconds pins are pins with noticeable flaws sold at a discount price. *Seconds may not come with a backing card!

Examples of expected Seconds Grade imperfections:

Small smudges and/or staining
Minor metal tarnishing
Small Unfilled/Overfilled areas
Some oxidization of the metal
Noticeable/deep scratches
Low fills in larger or visually important areas
Dust or Dents in the Enamel

Each pin is unique and will contain different imperfections. Please be careful that you purchase the correct pin grade based on the above grading policy as you agree to accept the item AS IS once a purchase has been completed.